Groundwater Dependent Ecosystems

Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world. Indeed, it is the only thing that ever has.
— Margaret Mead

Don't wait for the cavalry to come over the hill to save you. You are the cavalry and had better save yourselves.
— Robert Lee Paul

Glyph of Ram

Groundwater Dependent Ecosystems

There is an unwanted perennial in Anza-Borrego Desert State Park

In 2021, the Tubb Canyon Desert Conservancy (TCDC) launched an ambitious scientific effort to answer a question central to the future of the Borrego Valley: Are there groundwater dependent ecosystems (GDEs) in the basin as defined by California's Sustainable Groundwater Management Act (SGMA)? Following a competitive review process, TCDC secured more than $1 million in Proposition 68 funding to support the research. The study was led by Dr. Travis Huxman, Chair of the Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology at the University of California, Irvine, with botanical investigations conducted by Dr. Jon Rebman, Director of Botany at the San Diego Natural History Museum.

The research team published its first Technical Memorandum in March 2023, demonstrating that the Borrego Valley Groundwater Sustainability Plan had relied on flawed data in concluding that no groundwater dependent ecosystems exist in the valley. In May 2025, the research team released its comprehensive final report, presenting four independent lines of scientific evidence that the mesquite bosque surrounding the Borrego Sink is, in fact, a groundwater dependent ecosystem under SGMA. The report represents the most extensive and rigorous investigation ever conducted on the relationship between groundwater and the Borrego Sink mesquite bosque. Yet despite these findings, the Borrego Watermaster has not formally acknowledged the report as the best available science regarding the bosque, nor recognized that the ecosystem meets SGMA's definition of a groundwater dependent ecosystem. The pages that follow document the science, the findings, and the ongoing effort to ensure that this unique desert ecosystem receives the recognition and protection it deserves.

Technical Memorandum

  • 2023-03-25_Technical_Memorandum.pdf
    This technical memorandum reviews the scientific basis for the Borrego Subbasin Groundwater Management Plan's conclusion that the Borrego Sink mesquite bosque is no longer groundwater dependent. The authors identify significant data gaps and argue that mesquite roots may extend much deeper than previously assumed, groundwater may be shallower in parts of the bosque, and earlier mapping and NDVI analyses substantially underestimated the bosque's extent and ecological condition. As a result, the report concludes that existing evidence is insufficient to dismiss groundwater dependence and recommends additional field studies, updated mapping, and direct measurements of groundwater use.

2024-February | Project Update

  • 2024-02-29_Project-Update.pdf
    This update presents early evidence that the mesquite bosque near the Borrego Sink functions as a groundwater-dependent ecosystem (GDE). Using mapping, remote sensing, evapotranspiration estimates, and isotope analyses, the study identified approximately 1,800 acres of mesquite habitat and estimated groundwater use of roughly 515-557 acre-feet per year, supporting the conclusion that mesquite are actively using groundwater.

2024-November | Project Update

  • 2024-11-19_Project_Update.pdf
    This update provides direct isotopic evidence that mesquite trees near the Borrego Sink obtain a majority of their water from groundwater, with groundwater contributing approximately 55-83% of water found in plant tissues. Additional findings from water potential measurements, evapotranspiration monitoring, biodiversity surveys, and remote sensing further strengthen the conclusion that the mesquite bosque is a groundwater-dependent ecosystem with significant ecological value.

Final Report

  • 2025-05-15-Final-Report.pdf
    The final report concludes that the Borrego Sink mesquite bosque is a confirmed groundwater-dependent ecosystem and beneficial groundwater user under California's Sustainable Groundwater Management Act. Drawing on multiple lines of evidence, including groundwater depth modeling, isotope analysis, water stress measurements, evapotranspiration monitoring, biodiversity surveys, and remote sensing, the report estimates about 1,850 acres of mesquite bosque are groundwater dependent and recommends incorporating its protection into future groundwater management decisions.

Public Comments/Correspondences to Watermaster

AI Summary of each linked file

  • 2025-07-02_wm-letter.pdf
    Dr. David Garmon argues that spending substantial Watermaster funds to verify the UCI mesquite bosque study as “best available science” is unnecessary because it is already the only comprehensive scientific study on the subject. He proposes lower-cost alternatives, including a simple literature review or expert evaluation, and urges the Board to accept the study as the foundation for managing the groundwater-dependent mesquite bosque.
  • 2025-09-17_wm-letter.pdf
    This letter contends that the UCI GDE Study clearly meets the Watermaster’s Best Available Science policy, while Appendix D4 lacks scientific rigor and was never intended to serve as definitive science. The author criticizes the Watermaster’s proposed year-long review process as unnecessarily expensive and argues that recognizing the UCI study as BAS should be separated from decisions about how to respond to its findings.
  • 2025-11-03_wm-letter.pdf
    This letter expresses confidence that the UCI GDE Study will ultimately be recognized as the Best Available Science regarding the Borrego mesquite bosque, citing a public statement by the author of Appendix D4 that the UCI study now represents the best available science. The author contends that continued reliance on Appendix D4 is no longer defensible and urges the Watermaster to move forward without further delay or unnecessary expense.
  • 2025-12-17_wm-letter.pdf
    Dr. Garmon argues that Appendix D4’s conclusion that no groundwater-dependent ecosystems exist in the Borrego Subbasin is no longer scientifically defensible, citing admissions by its author and findings from UCI’s research. The letter urges the Watermaster to recognize the UCI study as the best available science and discontinue reliance on Appendix D4, which allegedly omitted most of the mesquite bosque and relied on flawed assumptions and limited data.
  • 2026-03-31_letter-to-wm.pdf
    Dr. Garmon argues that the UCI research team has fully responded to all written critiques of its GDE study and that those responses expose significant errors in the reviews submitted by TAC, EWG, and the Technical Consultant. He urges the Technical Consultant to explicitly incorporate or address the UCI responses in any future recommendations.
  • 2026-04-08_letter-to-wm.pdf
    Dr. J. David Garmon informs the Borrego Watermaster that a majority (6 of 10) TAC/EWG members concluded the UCI GDE Report represents the best available science and demonstrates that the Borrego Valley Mesquite Bosque is a groundwater-dependent ecosystem (GDE). The letter urges the Watermaster Board to accept these findings and proceed accordingly.
  • 2026-05-20_letter-to-wm.pdf
    This letter argues that the scientific question of whether the mesquite bosque is a GDE has already been resolved by the UCI study, supported by multiple lines of evidence, a majority of TAC/EWG members, and The Nature Conservancy. The author criticizes the Watermaster for prolonging the review process through procedural delays and for failing to adequately recognize the conclusions of its own technical advisors.
  • 2026-06-03_letter-to-wm.pdf
    Dr. Garmon contends that the Watermaster's review process has been biased against the UCI study by excluding researchers' responses to critiques, omitting the majority TAC/EWG opinion from reports, and minimizing outside support from The Nature Conservancy. He also raises concerns about procedural fairness, transparency, and the cost effectiveness of the consultant-led review process.
  • 2026-04-TAC-EWG-Signature-Page.pdf

Article published in Borrego News

  • 2026-03-13-WM-Stonewalls-GDE-Science.pdf
    This document argues that a three-year University of California, Irvine (UCI) study found the Borrego Sink mesquite bosque is a groundwater-dependent ecosystem (GDE) and therefore should be protected under California's Sustainable Groundwater Management Act (SGMA).
    Key points:
    • UCI researchers used multiple scientific methods, including stable isotope analysis, evapotranspiration measurements, plant physiology monitoring, and satellite data. All methods indicated that mesquite trees are accessing groundwater.
    • The study found that 54% to 82% of the water in mesquite trees matched groundwater sources, suggesting significant groundwater reliance.
    • Critics questioned whether the bosque depends exclusively on groundwater, but the paper argues SGMA only requires that an ecosystem rely on groundwater at some point in its life cycle, not all the time.
    • Alternative explanations, such as long-term dependence on deep soil moisture, are described as unsupported by field data and inconsistent with desert hydrology.
    • UCI mapping found approximately 1,850 acres of mesquite woodland, far larger than the 13 acres identified in earlier planning documents, strengthening the case that groundwater is necessary to sustain the ecosystem.
    • The document concludes that the scientific evidence supports recognizing the bosque as a GDE and that groundwater managers should consider its protection when establishing pumping limits.

UCI Research Team’s responses to critiques:

  • UCI-Response-to-Critiques-2026 02-11.pdf
    This memo responds to comments from TAC, EWG, INTERA, and others regarding UCI's 2025 Groundwater Dependent Ecosystem (GDE) report. UCI maintains that multiple independent lines of evidence, including isotopes, evapotranspiration measurements, vegetation health analyses, and groundwater trends, consistently show that the approximately 1,850-acre Borrego Sink mesquite bosque relies on groundwater and qualifies as a GDE under SGMA. The authors argue that critiques emphasizing perched water, surface runoff, or soil moisture storage do not adequately explain the observed ecological patterns and do not overturn the study's conclusions.
  • UCI-Response-to-TAC-EWG-2026-03-12.pdf
    This follow-up memo addresses additional comments from West Yost and TAC/EWG members and reaffirms UCI's conclusion that substantial portions of the Borrego Sink mesquite bosque are groundwater dependent. The authors argue that SGMA does not require exclusive groundwater use, defend their isotope, evapotranspiration, and NDVI analyses, and contend that proposed alternative explanations based on deep soil moisture or runoff infiltration are unsupported by existing hydrologic science and field observations. The memo also supports proactive groundwater management and monitoring to protect the bosque while continuing to refine scientific understanding through additional data collection.

Latest News: Groundwater Dependent Ecosystem

President Letter Archive

Groundwater Dependent Ecosystem

Regional Decarbonization Framework